This was one of the best albums to come out in 2008, and it was totally unexpected for me - I wasn’t really (and I’m still not I guess) a big Kanye fan, considering he’s acted like a jerk on several occasions, but this album knows exactly how to get to me - auto-tuned vocals, the 808 drum machine, hop-hop that swings more towards funk/soul and electronic music then rap… so tasty.
It starts out strong - just listen to that gut-rumbling kick, and Kanye’s slightly FX’d vocals:
In the night, I hear ‘em talk,
the coldest story ever told
Somewhere far along this road, he lost his soul to a woman so heartless…
How could you be so heartless?
So the intro is the chorus, and all it takes is a clap and a caliope-sounding staccato chord line to moves us into the verse:
How could you be so, cold as the winter wind when it breeze, yo
Just remember that you talkin’ to me though
You need to watch the way you talkin’ to me, yo
I mean after all the things that we’ve been through
I mean after all the things we got into
Hey yo, I know of some things that you ain’t told me
Hey yo, I did some things but that’s the old me
I’m not sure why the ’street’ vocabulary doesn’t annoy me - normally a lot of that sort of slang turns me off, but in this context, “afta’ all da tings dat we been do, afta all da tings we got into” sounds… I don’t know, it sounds refined, almost cultured, like the narrator is trying to be reasonable with his girl, which I’m sure is exactly what it’s supposed to sound like. It works. The perky yet minimal hits that hit towards the end of the verse, into the chorus, keep with the ‘less is more’ approach that a lot of the tracks on this album take.
There’s more good lyrical candy in the second verse:
How could you be so Dr. Evil, you bringin’ out a side of me that I dont know…
I decided we weren’t gon’ speak so
Why we up 3 A.M. on the phone
Why does she be so mad at me fo’
Homie I dont know, she’s hot and cold
“How could you be so Doctor Evil?” Good stuff - and the short conversational “Why do she be so made at me fo? Homie I don’t know, she’s hot and cold,” line is so appealing, as far as the rythem and meaning goes.
And then there’s the bridge, where things get super grunged out for a second on the line, “and we jus’ gon’ be enemies.” It’s a nice quick break, before we get back to the chorus. That’s basicly all there is - no additional instrumentation, just some auto-tuned vocalizing.
I think a lot of my attraction to this song comes from its minimalism, and the fact that it’s telling a story. This is established in the first chorus right up front: “In the night, I hear ‘em talk, the coldest story ever told, somewhere far along this road, he lost his soul - to a woman so heartless…” It’s almost like a ghost story. This is good stuff.